The following content may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through the links below, I may receive compensation.

THE SILENCE OF THE GIRLS / MARTYR! / JAMES / ALL THE COLORS OF THE DARK / 33 PLACE BRUGMANN / LONG ISLAND
I’ve not been reading as much fiction as I normally do the past six months; I’ve instead been drawn to the creative practice of reading poetry most mornings when I settle into my studio. This is partly my own conscious embrace of the “fractionality” concept — i.e., knowing I don’t have as much time to read in longer stretches and accommodating little pockets of available time by reading sips of poetry instead — and partly because it’s what’s making me lean forward right now. I love the distillation of poetry, its elision and parataxis. Sometimes I re-read my prose and think, “now what would the poet do?” and weedwack about half the words off the page. Concision has never been my strong suit; I’m still learning to “kill my darlings.” Occupational hazard of the noticer, I guess — I want to leave it all in.
I have a couple of trips planned in the coming weeks and I’d like to take those occasions to dig into some novels, though. I miss the feeling of flopping, hammock-like, into a book.
Right now, I’m reading Pat Barker’s Silence of the Girls and my God does it scratch the itch Circe left years ago. I’m about a third of the way through and loving it, but my progress is stymied by the fact that I only seem able to read during that narrow crescent just before bed, when my mind swims as close to the rim of sleep as it can without actually slipping in. Not great; I find myself re-reading 1-2 pages each night. Have you read it? If not, disregard the following, but did anyone else get a small and strange thrill when Achilles cried as Briseis was taken by Agamemnon? I find his portraiture absolutely fascinating. I love the obliqueness of it (at least, as of 30% in) — it almost feels like Barker paints him in profile versus 3D. We see only the cut of his jib, but it’s closer-in than we’ve ever seen him before. The book is so cinematic; I’d love to see it adapted to screen. We’d need a Hemsworth brother for Achilles, and maybe like a Brie Larsen for Briseis? Natalie Portman also came to mind but she’s a bit too delicate for the way Briseis is written…

Next up: The Berry Pickers (check trigger warnings! I know a lot of you have written that you couldn’t stomach this one, as it has to do with the loss of a child) and then All the Colors of the Dark. These have been recommended dozens of times by Magpie readers and I need to see what all the buzz is about. A lot of you have specifically mentioned these books in the same breath as The God of the Woods, which I found gripping and pleasurable to read. (Full review here.)
I also always have a romance or two downloaded to my Kindle. They’re my escape valve when I’m fretting at 3 a.m. or killing time in a waiting room or some other unpleasant situation. I currently have B. K. Borison’s First Time Caller and Elsie Silver’s Wild Side downloaded but not started either. Heads up to check the spice level (i.e., open door vs. closed door) ratings from Beach Reads and Bubbly if you’re new to this genre!
Also on my radar…
+Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy — described as a literary thriller; people have been raving about the poetic quality of this work. “A family on a remote island. A mysterious woman washed ashore. A rising storm on the horizon.”
+Martyr by Kaveh Akbar. Have heard this is darkly funny, incisive, poetic — but realistic. “A newly sober, orphaned son of Iranian immigrants, guided by the voices of artists, poets, and kings, embarks on a remarkable search for a family secret that leads him to a terminally ill painter living out her final days in the Brooklyn Museum.”
+33 Place Brugman by Alice Austen — “An outstanding debut novel—a love story, mystery, and philosophical puzzle, told in the singular voices of the residents of a Beaux Arts apartment house in Belgium during World War II.”
+James by Percival Everett. I’ve had this downloaded for almost a year. I know I’ll get to it eventually!
+Long Island by Colm Toibin. When I polled Magpie readers on Instagram as to what they were reading, this was the number one response. (“From the beloved, critically acclaimed, bestselling author comes a spectacularly moving novel featuring Eilis Lacey, the complex and enigmatic heroine of Brooklyn, Tóibín’s most popular work in twenty years.”)
Not really my speed / grabbing me, but there’s a lot of buzz right now about the novel I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacquline Harpman (“Ursula K. LeGuin meets The Road in a post-apocalyptic modern classic of female friendship and intimacy.”). Has anyone read? Is it worth the hype?
What’s in your TBR (to be read) pile?
Reminder: embrace your bad book girl self.
Shopping Break.
+Big Madewell sale started yesterday — 25% off sitewide, and this includes their popular darted barrel jeans, which are almost always excluded from sale. I also love these in the butter yellow and this adorable raffia bag.
+So much great stuff at Farm Rio – this dress, this top! Such great Easter options, both.
+This floral vest is beyond adorable for little ladies. Pair with an inexpensive ribbed leggings set for an easy spring outfit.
+Obsessed with these pull-on pants from Banana.
+Our table from Oomph finally arrived (like eight or ten months after ordering!), and it’s so cute…I also like the look of this fun Serena and Lily option if you’re also looking for a pop of color but don’t want the wait (or price tag). Bonus: it’s 20% off.
+CHIC statement shorts at a great price. Pair with a polished tank like this.
+Why do I love this Gucci tote so much…
+Another really pretty spring top. Love this tucked into mid-wash denim or ecru pants.
+My inner prep is finding it difficult to resist this striped tank. It’s very Ralph-meets-Abercrombie but grown up.
+Speaking of our inner prep — the kind of classic oxford dress you can live in. Imagine barefoot on a beach, over a striped bikini. And I’m also swooning over this Reformation dress, which also has a great throwback prep vibe. I had so many pieces like this!
+Ordered this striped performance polo for my son in the lavender stripe! Love when brands offer more than just red or blue for boys.
+Pretty and very well-priced patio umbrella. Serena and Lily vibes!
+Wait – these little loafers for boys remind me of the Loro Piana Summer Walk loafers, which seem to be sold out all the time! I’ve been wanting to snag a pair for Landon for months now. I might get him these similar Brunello Cucinellis instead.
+Fab spring trousers.
I read I Who Have Never Known Men and was blown away. Highly recommend. I also recently read “So Big” by Edna Ferber, for which she won the Pulitzer in 1925 and felt her social commentary was as applicable now as it apparently was 100 years ago.
Thank you!! Love hearing what you’re reading. IWHNKM has been so polarizing but this makes me want to read it! Thanks!
I just finished Martyr! and thought it was excellent – sharp, beautiful, and original. Will be interested to hear your take on the end! I read The Rabbit Hutch last year and second the recommendation – it was very good, and also original. I am on waitlists for The Berry Pickers and Wild Dark Shore. I loved Charlotte McConaghy. Her first book Migrations was spectacular – gorgeous, atmospheric. I listened to it, and thought the narrator was perfect. I believe in the seasonality of books (much like wine), and think it is a book best appreciated in cooler weather. Since Martyr!, I have picked up and put down a few things, and mostly been captivated by Severance. Planning to start People Collide after tonight.
You’re making me so excited to dig into these! Can’t wait to compare notes!! Will be writing full reviews as I finish them. Please continue to share thoughts / what you’re reading! It sounds like our tastes might be similar.
xx
My top book of 2024 was Orbital by Samantha Harvey–I never would have thought I’d like a book about astronauts in a space station orbiting the earth but boy does it capture the bigness and smallness of living. The prose is so good, meditative, subtle and the imagery vividly transports you to the foreign world of an orbiting space station. I found just the premise of being able to imagine myself falling through space had a profound effect on the experience of reading the book.
Right now am 70 pages into The Rabbit Hutch by Tess Gunty which won the national book award in 2022 but I had a baby on 1/2 of that year so totally missed it. It is SO GOOD. The kind of writing that makes you appreciate how flexible language is. She has so many surprising and astute sentences.
“The bigness and smallness of living” – wow, you had me at that description! Adding to my TBR!
Love the way you talk books. Evocative!
xx
I just finished Horse by Geraldine Brooks, James before that – both are early contenders for my favorite book of the year. James was a book club pick, which I’d recommend – it’s an incredible piece of literature but heavy, so it helped to have a group discussion of the nuances and depictions of the various horrors of slavery. Horse also toggles between pre-Civil War South and modern day, but I found the research behind the plot fascinating (based on elements of a true story!). It partially takes place in DC, which is always fun as a resident. All the Colors of the Dark is waiting on my Kindle, after I finish a nice, zippy palate cleanser of a thriller (Bye, Baby right now – actually, really really good). Love comparing notes with other avid readers!
I started but didn’t finish “Horse” – enjoyed it but it wasn’t the right fit for my emotional state when I read it. I remember vividly imagining one of the scenes taking place on R Street where I used to live, and so even now, when I drive that way, I think fleetingly of that book! Maybe I need to pick it up again.
Thanks for all these recs!
The ending is SO emotional, so it sounds like you made the right choice for your stage of life. I had the same experience with Demon Copperhead… I wanted to complete it so badly, but the initial chapters about young child neglect/abuse of the mother hit me way too hard as a new parent (at the time).
Yes – so important to listen to what you have the bandwidth for!
I’m also glad you’re enjoying The Silence of the Girls, I had a hunch you would. I remember finding the prose sparse in places but also evocative which is my favourite combination.
Currently, I’m reading The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood. My exploration of Atwood before this had really only been The Handmaid’s Tale and it’s follow up. In every other attempt I’ve made at an Atwood novel, I’ve been tripped up in the first few chapters or something just hasn’t quite clicked. I’d been warned that might happen with The Blind Assassin and it did, but I persevered, making slow progress until around 150 pages, but now I’m about halfway through at 300ish pages, and I’m so happy I stuck with it. It’s a marvel; the imagery is incredible, the tightly-wound plot is slowly unfurling and I keep looking for excuses to sneak away from my studio to race through another page or two. Obviously, it’s got huge literary merit; it won the Booker Prize. But I’m pleased that it’s turning into an enjoyable read too. Can recommend. It’s also nice to make my way through a backlist title for a change, instead of prioritising the new releases in my (very substantial) TBR pile!
Oh interesting! Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Atwood. I am going to astound everyone by saying I’ve never read any Atwood. Sometimes I have this irrepressible philistinism and when “Handmaid’s Tale” was all the rage, I just…couldn’t clip in? I am long overdue…maybe I’ll start with The Blind Assassin.
I love the way you captured Barker’s sparse and evocative prose — it’s so true. It also feels “right” for the time period. Even the phrase “we shared a dish of wine” (which has come up about 34444 times in 200 pages) feels just perfect. Slightly awkward and antiquarian, and also poetic and liquid.
xx
I’m so glad you’re enjoying Silence of the Girls! I completely agree about a new screen adaptation. Reading it reminded me of the movie Troy, (which I formatively watched with a gaggle of 14 year olds on a snow day in high school, haha) and MAN talk about a stacked cast! An average movie but wow, it is star-packed. I was thinking of someone like Florence Pugh for Briseis. Once I imagined her in the role, it could only be her! I review the book on my podcast bookfare, too, where we also talked about the upcoming Odyssey adaption. An exciting year ahead for greek lit fans!
I just finished Dream State (not good) and listened to Demi Moore’s memoir while walking the dog (very good) and am now in the middle of Ali Smith’s newest, Gliff (excellent so far.) To everyone looking for their next read– my favorite of 2024 was Loved and Missed by Susie Boyt, which made my ALL time favorites list. Tender, heartwrenching, gorgeously written. It’s superb in every sense.
Loved and MIssed made my top of 2024 list too. Beautiful writing and completely heartbreaking.
This has got to make its way to the top of my TBR! Tysm for sharing!
I watched Troy for the first time after finishing Silence of the Girls last year – my husband was THRILLED when I requested to watch & to join me in my inaugural viewing, ha!
Ooo!
Oo thanks for all of these! I enjoy a celebrity memoir so might need to DL Demi Moore’s. Was just thinking I like to have something like that on deck for when folding laundry, doing skincare / red light mask, etc. Thank you!
Immediately added the Boyt book to my list!
xx
I cannot resist a book discussion! I’m reading The Night We Lost Him by Laura Dave (decent but I’m kinda annoyed by the protagonist) and Mere Christianity, which I’ve been meaning to read for ages. I went on a tear recently and decided to put most of my goodreads “want to read” books on hold at the library. They’re mostly backlist so they’re coming in hot! I have quite the stack at my bedside. Hoping I can renew many times and get through all of them! Next up might be His &Hers by Alice Feeny, or The Blue Hour by Paula Hawkins.
A gorgeous little TBR pile you have!! Please share favorites when you’ve made your way through!
xx
I’ve been on a bit of a Greek mythology re-telling kick lately. I enjoyed ‘Silence of the Girls’ and am currently reading ‘Horses of Fire’ a re-telling of the Trojan War from the perspective of 3 Trojan women. It’s very enthralling so far, pulling different personality facets than I’ve seen in other books. I also finished ‘Hera’ which was imo not the best but still entertaining.
The Berry Pickers and All the Colors of the Dark were both exceptional! Thus far my top reads of 2025. I’m looking forward to reading the ‘Goddess of Warsaw’ and ‘Wild Dark Shore’ though there is quite a wait for them both at the library.
My book club read Martyr! last year, would love to hear your thoughts once you’ve finished!
Oh I’m so glad to hear the rave reviews of The Berry Pickers and ATCOTD. I’m now 70% done with Silence of the Girls so ready to move into those!
Will be reading Wild Dark Shore after.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
xx
“Let Them” by Mel Robbins. I am generally not a big fan of self help books but really enjoying this book.
I keep hearing about this book! Let me know your review when you’re done, please!
xx