Motherhood
14 Comments

The Magpie Diary: Oct. 12, 2025.

By: Jen Shoop

Oh, we have been in the sticky, swampy bits of parenting the past week. New attitudes, big moods, “It’s not fair!” echoing in the halls. I think often of that quote “don’t let your storm get your children wet,” and I use it to audit myself when I’m finding friction at home, but this past week, I am confident, I was bringing no blustery weather system to the family, and was emerging wind-tossed and sodden all the same. It’s OK; I am the mother. I am not my children’s friend, I am their parent. I am strong enough to meet this moment…! (The kinds of things I’ve been panic-whispering to myself when what I really want to do is loosen the grip on our rules, give in to things, make a swan-like peaceful glide across the surface, straight into storytime at bed). I tell you, this is a tricky business: how to handle situations where other parents give their children things that your children also want but that you do not permit, or cannot accomplish. For example, an extra serving of cookies; a last minute visit to the playground. I can empathize with the injustice! I can remember that “othered” feeling, too — the way my mother used to make me dress a certain way for cotillion when all the other girls were wearing modern shapes and high heels. And so I know all the sides, and also know that love is setting boundaries, and knowing what’s best for your children, no matter how difficult the context. It’s just so deeply unpleasant, though — can I say that?! How often I wish I could just bend to give. But I know the fallacy of that thinking; then it’s a negotiation at every point in the future. Better to set the line here and stand firm in it.

Mom, how did you do this? With five? You once told me: “say yes as often as you can so that when you say no, they know you mean it.” I sometimes feel I’m 90% no; I’m a font of “no”; I’m the alpha and omega of “no, no, no.” What am I missing? How I am not seeing this the right way?

I was, strangely, bolstered this weekend when I overheard one mother tell her daughter at a playground play date: “You can choose a dessert or a juice, not both,” and then bear the brunt of her daughter’s outrage, as all the other children tucked into both the capri sun and the cookie. I thought: “I see you, mama. I am you!” I wanted to pat her on the back for her courage. Because it’s not only the conviction to hold firm on a rule for your children, but also — to do it publicly, when all the parents are tacitly indicating that they condone a different path. Bravo! Tiny parade for you. I should have said something. But then I was teetering on the knife’s edge of indecision: my daughter came to me, sobbing, because she’d slid down a puddled slide, and was embarrassed and dripping wet, and we were only 15 minutes into the play date. What do we do?! Do I take her home? Do I listen to her pleas, her enormous tears? Or do I reassure her that her clothes will dry? That it’s OK to be uncomfortable? That it’s just a little water? There was also the logistical weighing on me: I was one of the coordinating hosts of the playdate and it felt wrong/rude/uncomfortable? to abandon the group. My daughter also had a soccer game immediately after the playdate in the same neighborhood, and it felt absurd to drive all the way home for a pair of shorts just to return 40 minutes later. Reader, we stayed. Within five minutes, she was off running around happily. Her shorts dried. A little friend of hers squirted water on herself in solidarity. But then, too — I was a no.

I have no answers here, just a from-the-front-line report on the ongoing clash between my desire to be the reed that bends and my lot — my call? my need? — to be the firm-rooted oak.

Today, I must remember that love bears all things, and certainly the love baked into my motherhood overrides my personal preference to accommodate and soothe. A mother must be many things, sometimes things she does not wish to be: this is a hard truth.

So onward, Magpie moms,

let’s try again —

Post-Script.

Writing this (forgive the blood-letting; my keys are stained, I tell you) reminded me of a piece I wrote earlier this year, in which I observed: “Mothers undergo tremendous transformation ever single day.  We shapeshift into the oak-tree of a firm “no,” the eiderdown of a soft landing, the morning rays that gently coax, the quiet night that holds the peace. I can meet this transition, and whatever it asks of me, too.” I am dissolving myself into those words, that headspace. Let me anoint this day with its energy.

On the theme of motherhood: this Thursday (!), my collaboration with the artist Riley Sheehey goes live! It is a charming collection of motherhood prints featuring her whimsical artwork and my writings on the wilderness and wonder of being a mother. I cannot wait to share! You’ll be able to shop from my site or hers! The Notes to Self is, frankly, something I need to sit with on a daily basis; I’m framing and keeping within my line of sight at my desk. I think I will put the other two in my son’s room (it’s blue and white); these are such beautiful pieces for a little one’s nursery!

Sunday Shopping (Football Break Shopping).

The main thing I was excited to snag this week was this ballet pink fitness set (shorts, bra, sweatshirt) from Vuori. The color is so charming.

Also wanted to mention that in the cover photo for this post, you see the Sezane Emile sweater — SO GOOD for this time of year. Heavyweight and warm; acts like a jacket. Love it layered over pointelle!

Other items on my radar:

+Still not over the assortment of fall Farm Rio dresses at The Outnet. This mini is so cute! I like a dress like this with a tall boot like this. Another dress in a similar silhouette from another brand we love: this Me+ Em. Such a great paisley! I for some reason imagine layering beneath a statement vest.

+A new mask I’m testing from a beauty brand that started as a spa!

+Love this knit take on a barn jacket. At time of writing, it’s on sale for under $100!

+Chic home finds: this kilim stool, this art book featiromg one of my favorite artists, this marbleized lamp shade.

+Fabulous fall napkins from Caspari.

+The chicest home gift. I brought one back for myself from Florence last fall and now give as gifts! They smell insanely good.

FARM RIO DRESS // ANN MASHBURN BOOT // ME + EM MINI // KILIM STOOL // LAMP SHADE // KANDINSKY BOOK // NATURA BISSE MASK // AURELIA DEMARK HEART CHARM // J. CREW SWEATER BARN JACKET // VERONICA BEARD WIDE LEG CORDS (LOOK FOR LESS HERE) // CASPARI NAPKINS // SCENTED CLAY

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through the links above, I may receive compensation.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

14 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Aoife
Aoife
22 days ago

Dear Jen, but also dear all of the beautiful pals sharing their experiences on this piece,
My husband and I aren’t parents (still a big question mark) however I’m pinning this to my secret Pinterest as a reference for if this is in our future. Moreover, just reading this offers invaluable insight into all of the ways life shifts and what the responsibilities of being a parent are. When so many people I adore more than I could say are in this walk of life, being able to read some of your experiences along with your reflections is powerful teaching that it’s not just about being a parent — it’s a minute-by-second-by-millisecond journey. I really appreciate this.
And lastly: I worked in high schools in Australia in student wellbeing and community engagement. I’ve seen many, many things that I couldn’t begin to communicate. Loving and being present with kids as they grow into young people then young adults is always what they need. You’re all doing amazing xx

Claire
Claire
22 days ago

Also.. as a pediatrician, I LOVE that you stated that you are your kids mom NOT their friend. So many people don’t understand how important that it.

Claire
Claire
22 days ago

Jen- I love reading your musings on parenthood. It is an every evolving and difficult task for sure. I am currently navigating three moody teenagers. It’s always a learning process. I love what your mom told you “say yes as often as you can so that when you say no, they know you mean it.” This is my new mantra!

Stephanie
Stephanie
22 days ago

Wow, I am right there with you! There are just SO MANY requests…they fire them at me one after the other, without even thinking. I, too, feel like a fount of no! We’re going through it right now in 3rd grade with Kpop demon hunters. I’ve said no, it’s for older kids, but it’s tough bc other parents clearly think it’s for 3rd graders (and younger). I’ve been repeating the mantra of different families have different rules, but it’s still hard to answer “why?” without saying something that comes across as judgmental to other parents and could very well be parroted by my child to their child (or even to the parents in question). It’s exhausting! Solidarity!

Clare
Clare
23 days ago

I know exactly what you mean here! I always find it helpful to think, If they cannot trust us on these boundaries we have set, if we tell them they exist and then allow them to fade away, what can they trust us on? I want my daughter to be a woman of her word, so I must be too!

Kelly
Kelly
23 days ago

Jen, I feel this!! I’m such a font of no. I do feel discomfort on the other side too when I say yes to another cookie for my daughter and my friend is saying no, but it’s a good chance for them to see that different families have different rules and values, and each mom has a good reason!

I because I’m naturally a very yes mom, lately my kids after school get more and more ridiculous in their demands to force a no and give themselves the chance to release some tears. I usually say yes to some things my peers say no to (yes on the cookie, yes on the chips, yes on the food of any kind, yes on the movie if it’s within prescribed tv time, yes on the playground for two hours, yes to coming in our room any time of night, yes to getting messy, yes to bodily autonomy and independence and anything that fosters that), but I’m very no on: buying more new things or clothes or toys, doing anything I feel is unsafe (in the emotional sense even if technically the kids are still safe, just pushing limits), no on bothering daddy in his office, no on being impolite, no on getting up from the dinner table once I’ve sat down, no loud noises indoors, no playing in my bed. My kids push me a lot on my nos I think partly because they want to know the line but also because all my nos are yeses for my in-laws! They always say yes to a new toy, but they always say no to going to the playground. Limits are love! I keep telling my kids that one of the joys of being clear in our nos and listening to each others’ nos are the depth and strengthening of our bonds.

Stephanie
Stephanie
21 days ago
Reply to  Jen Shoop

I love this snack rule, Jen! I’m going to figure out a similar one that will work for us. As my kindergartener is adjusting to full school days, most of her meltdowns are snack-related, so maybe more guardrails will help…

Previous Article

Next Article