We compiled all Magpie recipes into beautiful cards for your kitchen! Get the recipe card collection in your inbox here.
If you want more Magpie, you can subscribe to my Magpie Email Digest for a weekly roundup of top essays, musings, conversations, and finds!
I have tried many Mexican Wedding cookie recipes over the years — they’re actually one of my favorite styles of cookies — and finally found the perfect one, from Gonzalo Guzman’s cookbook, Nopalito. I made them last weekend as a part of a Mexican-themed dinner party, serving them for dessert alongside two flavors of paletas (also from the Nopalito cookbook): chocolate-cinnamon and lime-cream. All were delicious but, frankly, the polvorones stole the spotlight. I was delighted to see my guests reaching for seconds…and thirds…and fourths! as the candles burned low and final glasses of wine and pours of mezcal were enjoyed.
These buttery cookies melt in your mouth and have a distinctive, warm nuttiness to them thanks to not only the standard ground almonds, but the recipe’s insistence that you toast the flour (something I’d never done before in my long baking career) and swap all-purpose flour for cake flour. These fine points yield an excellent result: the polvorones boast incredible depth of flavor and a wonderful texture that, while crumbly, has a velvetiness I’ve never been able to achieve in this style of cookie.
Enjoy —
Polvorones (Mexican Wedding Cookies)
Adapted from Nopalito
Makes about 3-4 dozen small cookies
Ingredients:
1/2 cup raw almonds
18 oz (about 3 3/4 cups) cake flour
1/4 cup granulated sugar
3/4 tsp baking powder
3/4 tsp kosher salt
3/4 tsp ground cinnamon (we buy ours from Spice House — I notice such a difference when I use higher quality spices vs. McCormick; we are also diligent about throwing spices away after a year, as they lose their intensity of flavor over time)
10 oz (2.5 sticks) unsalted butter, melted (I use Kerrygold or Plugra in all baking — the butter quality makes SUCH a big difference!)
3/4 tsp vanilla extra (I like Nielsen-Massey)
powdered sugar, for dusting
Preparation:
Preheat oven to 375. Add almonds to a small baking sheet and spread flour on a separate baking sheet. Bake both until almonds are toasted and the flour is a dark cream color. [Jen note: The cookbook advises 20 minutes for this step, but I found the almonds were toasted within about 10 minutes — use your nose to determine doneness! Once you start smelling the almonds, they’re toasted. You do not want burnt nuts! The flour took a lot longer — maybe 30 minutes?]. Remove and let cool completely (otherwise the almonds will turn to almond butter when ground). Lower the oven heat to 350.
In a food processor [Jen note: I use this mini size and everything fit fine], combine the cooled almonds, sugar, baking powder, salt, and cinnamon and process until almonds are finely ground.
Transfer the mixture to a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment and beat in the melted butter and vanilla on low speed. Add the toasted flour and mix on low speed until just incorporated.
Line baking sheets with parchment. Using a small cookie scoop or melon baller, place level scoops of dough on the prepared pans 1.5 inches apart. Bake, rotating pans halfway through, until evenly browned and cooked through, about 30 minutes. [Jen note: Mine took much less time — closer to 18-20 minutes — and I again knew they were done by smell.]. Remove and dust with powdered sugar while still hot. [Jen note: I filled a small bowl with powdered sugar and tossed the cookies in the sugar one by one to ensure even coating. You want them fully covered, caked in sugar.]
Let cool completely. These will keep for several days if stored in an airtight container.
Post-Scripts.
+Lessons learned from cooking and entertaining.
+More great fall baking recipes.
+Sometimes, constraints are a good thing.
+The fallacy of open time.
Shopping Break.
+For melting butter, I have been eyeing this Dansk saucepan in the 1 qt size. We use our smallest 1 qt All-Clad pot CONSTANTLY. So handy to have a small size for things like soups, melting butter, thawing small portions of stock, preparing small servings of frozen veg for the kids, etc. (And for even smaller batches — like a few tablespoons butter for dipping lobster — we use this tiny butter warmer from Mauviel.) I think it’d be nice to have another in this size but in the charming Dansk style. You can get 20% off (sitewide, actually!) at Food52 with code Magpie20. More of my favorites from their collection here.
+All my favorite baking gear here, plus a list of some fantastic kitchen items you might not have here.
+This $150 sweater reminds me of the style/silhouette I bought from Jenni Kayne.
+This $160 dress is spectacular for a fall wedding — LOVE in the emerald color. Very Ulla J. Imagine with velvet platforms (also someone please snag these spectacular green velvet platforms from The Real Real in a size 9) with one of the emerald rings Dorsey’s about to launch.
+This Goop cardi is a total splurge but I can’t tell you how much I’ve loved their Beckham sweater this summer. I literally keep it at my desk. Think I might invest in this pretty gray one for my winter desk sweater. The quality and tailoring of this brand has totally blown me away. Simple, elevated basics. A stylist recently said that she invests in one good knit each season. This Goop one might be mine!
+OMG love this sherpa pullover from Old Navy. The length is so good, and the green color is fantastic. More great fall athleisure here.
+I’ve been seeing lots of chunky gold earrings this season — test the trend with this $10 pair!
+A few great pairs of olive green cords to consider: Apiece Apart, SPRWMN, Paige (on sale!), and these Gaps.
+A Magpie wrote requesting “fun pops of red” for her wardrobe and I think we all need this $89 oversized red cableknit cardigan. SO GOOD.
+Obsessed with this marigold-colored tablecloth for fall…might use for my Thanksgiving table?!
+Insane splurge, but a fall ballcap from Celine or Miu Miu would be SUCH a great exclamation point on your fall wardrobe.
+I have two new fall candles from Linnea en route to me: Embers and Bourbon Tabac. Bring on fall.
+For Magpies asking for fall/winter special occasion dresses while pregnant: this Sleeper dress!
+I keep coming back to this satin brown mini skirt. It’s SO good and so different?!
+A chic, inexpensive area rug for a big space at a great price.
My mouth is watering as I read about those cookies! Our favorite local bakery makes them with pecans and they are so delicious this way too. Bookmarking this recipe — thank you for sharing!
Interestingly, the Filipino polvoron also uses the same method of toasting the flour first. Ours is somewhat different though, in that we don’t bake them. We mix toasted flour, dry milk powder (sounds strange, I know), butter, and sugar, and add-ins like chopped toasted walnuts (not traditional, but my mom makes it this way and it’s my favorite) or toasted rice crispies. Then we have these polvoron molds to shape them into little ovals and wrap them in little squares of baking paper (like a candy). They are delicate and crumbly and buttery and just SO good. Totally agree with using high-quality butter, especially in recipes like these. Kerrygold forever!
I should add — my mom always toasted the flour in a large skillet instead of in the oven, that way she could mix it frequently and the flour would toast evenly.
Also a great suggestion. Might do this next time myself. It was sort of unwieldy to take the sheet out of the oven, stir, etc, every now and then.
xx
Oo the polvoron sounds so delicious — filing that away for a possible holiday cookie idea to pass out to neighbors? Love the idea of wrapping them individually like candies!
xx